In most cases, saving a natural tooth with root canal treatment is preferable to extracting it, provided the tooth can be restored and the outlook is good, because a natural tooth is hard to improve on and an extraction leaves a gap that may need to be replaced. There are, however, situations in which extraction is the better choice, and the right answer depends on the condition of the tooth and the patient’s circumstances.
The NHS says that without root canal treatment an infected tooth may need to be extracted, and it names the two as the main options. Comparing them properly means looking at the likely result, the cost over time and what each involves, and a dentist will advise on the particular tooth. This guide sets out the main considerations for root canal treatment and for extraction.
What each involves
Root canal treatment removes the infected pulp from the tooth, cleans and shapes the root canals and fills and seals them, and the tooth is then restored with a filling or crown, as the NHS describes in its page on root canal treatment. The tooth stays in place and continues to function.
Extraction removes the whole tooth under local anaesthetic. It is usually quicker, often completed in a single short appointment, but the socket needs to heal and the gap remains. The NHS page on tooth decay lists extraction as the treatment for severe damage.
| Feature | Root canal treatment | Extraction |
|---|---|---|
| What happens | Infected pulp removed; canals cleaned and sealed | Tooth removed under local anaesthetic |
| Result | Natural tooth kept | A gap remains |
| Visits | Usually two or more | Often one |
| Cost on the NHS in England | Band 2; crown is band 3 | Band 2 |
| Afterwards | Needs a filling or crown | Consider replacing the tooth |
| Best when | Tooth can be restored and outlook is good | Tooth is too damaged to save |
Reasons to save the tooth
Natural teeth have advantages. A root-treated tooth keeps its roots anchored in the jaw, so the bone is preserved and the neighbouring and opposing teeth stay in position. Chewing and appearance are unchanged, and there is no need for a replacement. If the tooth is restored well, it can last many years, often for life.
Saving the tooth can also be cheaper in the long run. The NHS charge for root canal treatment is a band 2 charge, and with a crown it is band 3, which compares well with the cost of replacing an extracted tooth with a bridge, a denture or an implant.
Reasons to extract
Extraction is sometimes the better course. A tooth that is too badly broken down to be restored, has a vertical crack that runs below the gum, has lost too much supporting bone through gum disease, or has already failed a root canal treatment and cannot be retreated may have a poor outlook. A patient with serious medical conditions, or who cannot tolerate long treatment, may also prefer extraction. Wisdom teeth and some baby teeth are routinely extracted instead of root-treated.
Where the likely success of root canal treatment is low, spending money and time on it may not be sensible, and a dentist should be candid about the odds.

Recovery compared
After a root canal, the NHS says the area may be swollen and sore, which should improve within a couple of weeks, and the face may stay numb for several hours. After an extraction, there is a socket to heal. Patients are advised to avoid rinsing hard, smoking and drinking hot liquids for the first day, to bite on gauze to control bleeding and to take painkillers as needed, and soreness typically lasts a few days. A dry socket, a painful complication in which the blood clot is lost, occurs occasionally and needs dental attention.
Replacing an extracted tooth
A gap does not always need filling, particularly at the back of the mouth, but leaving it can allow neighbouring teeth to tilt and the opposing tooth to overgrow, which may cause problems later. The options for replacement include a bridge, a denture or a dental implant, and the choice depends on position, health and budget. Our guide to dental implants and dentures compares two of them. Each has costs and maintenance, and it is wise to think about them before deciding on extraction.
Making the decision
The dentist’s advice is central. Questions worth asking include how likely the root canal is to succeed, what the tooth needs afterwards, what extraction and replacement would involve and cost, and what happens if no treatment is chosen. The NHS notes that an infected tooth will not heal alone, so doing nothing is rarely an option. A second opinion, or a referral to an endodontist for a difficult tooth, can help.

Success rates and long-term outcomes
Root canal treatment succeeds in most cases when the tooth can be properly cleaned and sealed and then protected with a good restoration. The outcome depends on the tooth, the shape of the canals, the thoroughness of the cleaning and the quality of the final filling or crown, and the Wikipedia article on the root canal notes that complex anatomy is the main cause of failure. A dentist can give a sense of the odds for a particular tooth and, if they are poor, say so. Extraction, in comparison, has a very high immediate success but leads to consequences that depend on whether and how the gap is replaced.
Pain and anxiety
Both procedures are carried out under local anaesthetic and are generally well tolerated. Some people fear root canal treatment because of its reputation, and others dislike the idea of losing a tooth. Sedation is available for anxious patients in many practices, and the dentist can explain what each procedure will feel like. It is more helpful to base the decision on the tooth’s prospects than on fear.
What happens if you do nothing
Doing nothing is rarely sensible. The NHS says a dental abscess will not go away on its own and needs urgent dental treatment, and an infected tooth normally gets worse. Antibiotics can control spreading infection but do not remove the source. Leaving an infected tooth risks pain, swelling, damage to the surrounding bone and, rarely, serious spread of infection, so the choice is between treatment options, not between treatment and nothing.
NHS and private options across the UK
Both treatments are available on the NHS where clinically appropriate and privately. In England, an extraction and a root canal both fall in band 2, and a crown is band 3, while urgent treatment has a lower charge. Charging for NHS dentistry differs across the four nations. England has three bands and an urgent charge, with root canal treatment in band 2, Wales numbered bands and an urgent charge with a contract reform under way, Scotland free examinations and free treatment under 26 with a capped share of the cost for other adults, and Northern Ireland a percentage of the dentist’s fee up to a ceiling per course. Replacement of an extracted tooth with a bridge or denture is available on the NHS in the highest band, whereas implants are mostly private.
Private fees vary. A root canal on a molar commonly costs from about £500 to £1,000 or more, and a crown extra, whereas an extraction is generally cheaper but may be followed by the cost of replacing the tooth.
Finding a practice
A dentist who explains both options without pressure, and who is willing to refer for specialist care when needed, is a good choice. Reading reviews and checking inspection reports provide additional reassurance.
The ChooseDentist directory of root canal practices can be searched by postcode, with CQC and Google ratings displayed where available. Two practices can be compared side by side, and the details of treatment and cost should be confirmed directly with the practice.
